Posted on August 30, 2025
ValuePengin, a LendingTree company, provides consumers with financial tools and information. Last month, they published the states with the highest and lowest auto insurance rate averages. Indiana is one of the least expensive.
The most expensive is Nevada, with an average of $286 per month, followed by Florida ($272), Michigan ($263), Louisiana ($249), Colorado ($241), Rhode Island ($237), Delaware ($230), Arizona ($218), Oklahoma ($200 -- that was as surprise I thought), and finally New Jersey at $199.
Indiana is 43rd, with an average of $130, with Maine as the least expensive at $103.